Legislative Policy Paper

Signature Assignment 2 (Unit 4): Legislative Policy Paper

Due February 7, by 11:59 pm

Paper must be double spaced, with 12 point font and include section headers for each of the paper sections noted below (Three Representational Roles and Role You Choose, Influence of Legislative Leaders, Rank and Explain Influences of Institutional Factors, and Explain Your Vote)

Objective: The objective for this assignment is for students to understand and critically analyze the multiple pressures on policy makers in Texas as they most listen to their leaders, the governor, the voters (social responsibility) and their own conscience (personal responsibility) in deciding how to cast their vote on a controversial issue.

Assignment: You have recently been elected as a Republican to the Texas Senate from a competitive district (even number of Democrats, Republicans and Independents) just outside of Dallas. One of the first bills that you must vote on is House Bill 3- a Bill to require the death penalty for anyone convicted of selling opioids for a third time. Your constituents support the bill as does the Governor your party, but you oppose it on grounds that the death penalty should be reserved for heinous crimes (pre-meditated murder). The Speaker of the House opposes the bill as well.

In explaining how you will vote on the bill, be sure to explain the following:

• List and discuss each representational role (trustee, delegate, politico). What Representational Role you will adopt (trustee, delegate or politico). (Unit 4 Written Lectures, Slide 4-25)
• How will the Speaker of the House, the Lt. Governor and Governor of Texas influence the fate of the bill? (Unit 4 Written Lectures, Slides 4-9, 4-10, 4-18 & 4-22 )
• How do you think constituents might try to influence your vote? (Unit 4 Written Lectures, Slide 4-20)
• Which factors noted above and in your notes (constituents, governor, party leaders and your own opinion) will influence your vote? Rank them in importance. (Unit 4, Written Lectures, Slide 4-20, 4-21)
• Will you vote for or against the bill? Please explain your answer thoroughly. You should refer back to the representational role here. (Unit 4 Written Lectures, Slide 4-25)

 

The paper should include subject headers (ie. Representational Roles, Influence of Legislative Leaders, etc.). The paper should be at least 3-4 pages in length.

 

 

Assessment: Your Assignment will be assessed based on the following rubric.

 

 

Percent

0 %

60%

80%

100%

Representational Roles

25%

No Effort

Notes at least one of three roles or lists, but does not explain all three.

Discusses all three roles, but does not apply to issue.

Thoroughly explains each role as well as why and how they chose to vote.

How do different people influence public policy?

25%

No Effort

Limited discussion of how each institutional factor can influence their decision.

Lists all people, but limited discussion of how they influence or does not discuss all people.

Thoroughly explains how leaders, governor, citizens and personal opinion can influence decision.

Rank and Explain Influences of institutional factors.

20%

No Effort

Ranks institutional factors, but limited explanation or does not rank all factors.

Ranks institutional factors, but does not thoroughly explain ranking of each.

Notes ranking of each institutional factor and thoroughly explains why each is ranked.

Explain your vote.

10%

No Effort

Yes or no vote with no explanation.

Yes or no vote with no reference to representational role and/ or institutional factors.

Expresses yes or no vote and explains importance of representational role and institutional factors.

Grammar/ Structure

10%

No Effort

Numerous grammatical and typographical errors, no headers.

Some grammatical and/ or typographical errors and/ or no headers.

Well written and well organized

Format

10%

No Effort

Not double spaced and not long enough.

Not double spaced or not long enough.

Double spaced and correct length.